konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

According to the news, Polsat has bought the rights to the infamous show.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Moment_of_Truth_(US_g...

"Prior to the show, a contestant is hooked up to a polygraph and asked more than 50 questions; there is no polygraph testing conducted during the actual show. Without knowing the results of the polygraph, he or she is asked 21 of those same questions again on the program, each becoming progressively more personal in nature. If the contestant answers honestly, according to the polygraph results, he or she moves on to the next question; however, should a contestant lie in his or her answer (as determined by the polygraph) or simply refuse to answer a question after it has been asked, the game ends. If he/she gives a false answer before the $10,000 level of questions, he/she leaves with nothing; after the $25,000 level, if a false answer is given, the contestant leaves with $25,000 (during the first season, a false answer on any level caused the player to leave with nothing). For each tier of questions answered correctly, the contestant wins the corresponding amount of money. A contestant may stop at any time before any question is asked and collect the money he or she has won. Although a person may stop after any question, once they hear the question, they must answer it or the game is over. Answering all 21 questions truthfully, as determined by the polygraph results, wins the jackpot of $500,000."

The episode that's been the most controversial so far:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-X4_GwpbUYY

Questions
Would you ever take part in a show like this? Do you think you might watch it? Is offering people half a million dollars for the truth (which they wouldn't otherwise divulge even to their partners or family) ethical?

(ideas pooled from Gazeta.pl, and Marcin's Etyka w praktyce group)Tatiana S. edytował(a) ten post dnia 13.08.08 o godzinie 12:09

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

Questions
Would you ever take part in a show like this? Do you think you might watch it? Is offering people half a million dollars for the truth (which they wouldn't otherwise divulge even to their partners or family) ethical?

I'd:

(a) watch it
(b) do it
(c) win it

I'm quite honest, and don't really have anything to hide.

Is it ethical?

Well, no-one's forced to take part.
Sylwia D.

Sylwia D. Człowiek Aktywny

Temat: The moment of Truth

Thet's a question what are we able to do for money ...
Many times (not only on TV) we can see people selling their privacy or even dignity just to "earn" money.
Few years ago we had "Big Brother" and it was also controversial. Participants of the show were ready for everything only to be shown on TV screen and to get money, of course.
People who take part in shows like this know exactly what are the rules and what to expect. It's their choice.

I wouldn't take part in it - money are not worth it. Secrets of people I don't even know personally are not interesting to me so watching the show would be a waste of time :) I'd rather take part in a show based on knowledge than on my private life.

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

Tatiana S.:
Would you ever take part in a show like this?
No. I see no value in it. It's just another Jerry Springer trash show.
Do you think you might watch it?
I might, but I wouldn't like to. What's the point?
Is offering people half a million dollars for the truth (which
they wouldn't otherwise divulge even to their partners or family) ethical?
I guess offering people money for anything which is humiliating for them or other people is not ethical. On the other hand, in case of the show, people APPLY for saying such truth, potentially humiliating themselves, and worse, their partners, family, and who else for money, right? Perhaps some of them do it for the sake of humiliation itself.

The ironic thing is that most participants probably really say the truth, because they think of the polygraph as of the God who knows everything. And so thinks the audience. While the polygraph in fact only observes physical reaction connected with stress, which may be caused by factors unconnected with lying. Those who know that and are relaxed good liers may say what they want.Kamila G. edytował(a) ten post dnia 13.08.08 o godzinie 13:24

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

It all boils down to whether we should always tell the truth, even if it's a very uncomfortable truth. Like the woman from the episede I provided a link for. "Honey, if I could have married my ex rather than you, well, I would have. Sorry I never told you".

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

Would I? That’s a definite no. I am pretty sickened by TV shows and the fact that our entertainment values have sunk so very, very low. I mean, you are watching someone trying to get caught lying. Ergh… huh? That’s about as entertaining as a drug induced coma.
Same goes for Big Brother type shows… it’s funny that none of the participants ever do anything messed up to each other. Now that would be the perfect way to win that show. I mean if the audience decides if you are staying or leaving… give them something to look forward to every week! It’s that easy! I mean… why don’t you pee in the pool while everyone is in it… just stand on the edge and take a leak! Or do something completely gross like feces painting on the living room wall, collect dirty hygienic pads and keep them in the freezer… anything goes.. it’s a million dollars right? Cameras in every room… that’s pretty much unlimited possibilities of entertainment, but instead they argue and fight over nothing… give them something substantial to get angry over, that would win you the money! Eh… people lack imagination.
Dariusz Tomczak

Dariusz Tomczak PONIEWAŻ OBECNIE
GOLDENLINE JEST
PASSE, NIE
AUKTUALNIAM P...

Temat: The moment of Truth

In my opinion, although the truth is extremely important it is not always ethical to say the truth if it may make somebody unhappy.

We shouldn't hurt anyone's feelings saying (completely honestly) that they are hopeless, are going to die from cancer soon, their spouses have someone else behind their back for instance.

The truth is of great value in itself, yet goodness is more important.

Remember "The Wild Duck" by Henrik Ibsen?

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

Tatiana S.:
It all boils down to whether we should always tell > the truth

I’ve found that honesty is bar far the best policy. It makes your life so much easier. When hiding something from the world or your close ones, you become heavy and sluggish mentally and physically, it just makes no sense.
That whole thing with “I’d marry my ex….” Well… that’s just not being honest with yourself more than your wife.
It goes same way for conducting business; honesty can go a long way. Keeping an honest relationship with your clients and business partners is probably the number one reason for a lot of healthy business venture’s success.

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

Dariusz Tomczak:

The truth is of great value in itself, yet
goodness is more important.

Goodness with out the truth is as shallow as empty promisses.

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

Rafal W.:
Tatiana S.:
It all boils down to whether we should always tell > the truth

I’ve found that honesty is bar far the best policy. It makes your life so much easier. When hiding something from the world or your close ones, you become heavy and sluggish mentally and physically, it just makes no sense.
That whole thing with “I’d marry my ex….” Well… that’s just not being honest with yourself more than your wife.
It goes same way for conducting business; honesty can go a long way. Keeping an honest relationship with your clients and business partners is probably the number one reason for a lot of healthy business venture’s success.

I agree.

That's why I'm honest ..... well, most of the time.

Temat: The moment of Truth

Tatiana S.:
It all boils down to whether we should always tell the truth, even if it's a very uncomfortable truth. Like the woman from the episede I provided a link for. "Honey, if I could have married my ex rather than you, well, I would have. Sorry I never told you".

Truth that's told with bad intent beats all the lies you can invent.

William Blake
Dariusz Tomczak

Dariusz Tomczak PONIEWAŻ OBECNIE
GOLDENLINE JEST
PASSE, NIE
AUKTUALNIAM P...

Temat: The moment of Truth

Rafal W.:

Goodness with out the truth is as shallow as empty promisses.

There are three areas of absolute:

TRUTH - BEAUTY - GOODNESS

There is also absolute power behind them, beyond human capacity, however.

Only God could be simultaneously absolutely good and absolutely just - what results in sacrificing his own son (Christ) to redeem human sins.

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

Would you take part in this show, Darek?

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

Dariusz Tomczak:

There are three areas of absolute:

TRUTH - BEAUTY - GOODNESS

There is also absolute power behind them, beyond human capacity, however.

Every human being is able to convey the truth; every one of us is able of displaying some of the most amazing acts of utmost random beauty just as every single human being on this planet is able to be good. These are hardly god like qualities; these are simply things that we’ve managed to develop through out thousands of years, just like our ability to communicate. Truth, beauty and goodness are just as natural to us as breathing. Truth is good and beautiful at the same time and it works the other way around, goodness is true and beautiful, just as beauty can be true and good. It is all up to each individual to nurture these qualities and it is perfectly with in the capability of even some of the most closed minded of us.

Only God could be simultaneously absolutely good
and absolutely just

You obviously don't have kids.

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

Dariusz Tomczak:
Only God could be simultaneously absolutely good and absolutely just - what results in sacrificing his own son (Christ) to redeem human sins.
Dave Andrew edytował(a) ten post dnia 13.08.08 o godzinie 15:26

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

I find it hardly good or just to sacrifice another human being (be it your son or otherwise) to prove a point.
Steve Jones

Steve Jones Business English
Trainer, Translator,
Proofreader

Temat: The moment of Truth

Dariusz Tomczak:
Rafal W.:

Goodness with out the truth is as shallow as empty promisses.

There are three areas of absolute:

TRUTH - BEAUTY - GOODNESS
No, they aren't. All three can be subjective

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth

Dariusz Tomczak:
Only God could be simultaneously absolutely good and absolutely just

Like in Rwanda, Darfur, Georgia etc.

konto usunięte

Temat: The moment of Truth


Obrazek
Dariusz Tomczak

Dariusz Tomczak PONIEWAŻ OBECNIE
GOLDENLINE JEST
PASSE, NIE
AUKTUALNIAM P...

Temat: The moment of Truth

warren whitmore:
Would you take part in this show, Darek?

I don't know what show you are referring to.

Następna dyskusja:

Your flava of the moment!




Wyślij zaproszenie do